In my new commute to a new job in Palo Alto, I have figured out the following options—with fully fleshed out pros and cons. With the consideration that I prefer to work normal hours like 9 to 5. All costs are determined on full cost without regards to passes or other bulk discounts.
Option 1: BART to Milbrae -> Caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 10 minutes
Total cost: $8.10
BART: $3.85
Caltrain: $4.25
Ideal time of departure: 7:47 am
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am
Pros: Least amount of walking, public transit only,
Cons: Expensive, transfer between transit agencies (no discount for transfer), bulk discount does not help
Option 2: SF Muni Bus to Caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 5 minutes (according to 511.org)
Total cost: $7.50
SF Muni: $1.50
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: unknown
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am or later
Pros: Least amount of walking, public transit only, I will likely get a fast pass
Cons: This specific bus is very unreliable (511 claims it’s only 17 minutes, but it’s actually 40 minutes; sometimes it stops halfway; goes through the projects), too much stress from unreliable public transit
Option 3: BART downtown, bus to 4th/King, Caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 20 minutes
Total cost: $7.50
SF Muni: $1.50
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: 7:45 am approximately
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am or later
Pros: Have taken this route before and mostly reliable, great station at 4th/king, useful if have fast pass
Cons: SF Muni T and N line get stuck in the tunnels, buses are inconsistent, angry homeless people slow down muni often, too much transit agency transfers, expensive, too much stress from unreliable public transit, too early in the morning
Option 4: Get a ride to caltrain station, then caltrain
Duration: 55 minutes
Total cost: $6.00
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: 8:05 am
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am
Pros: Least amount of walking, comfortable, no problem with guilt tripping
Cons: There won’t always be someone to drive me
Option 5: Drive to caltrain station, park, then caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 5 minutes
Total cost: $7.00
Estimated cost of car: $1.00 (unknown)
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: 7:45 am
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am
Pros: Self-sufficient and independent, have a car allowing for flexibility
Cons: Where will I park my car? Near my apartment? At the station? Have to account for parking tickets
Option 6: Carpool from San Francisco to Palo Alto
Duration: 35 minutes with no traffic, up to 1 hour in typical traffic
Total cost: unknown
Ideal time of departure: unknown
Estimated time of arrival: unknown
Pros: Cool conversation, new palo alto buddy, relaxing, can sleep in car, door-to-door service
Cons: No carpool lane until Redwood city, most drivers to Palo Alto take the 280 which means downtown Palo Alto is very out of the way, those who do commute to downtown Palo Alto leave at 11 am and return at 8 pm
Option 7: Bike to caltrain 4th/king, caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 10 minutes
Total cost: $6.00
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: unknown
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am
Pros: Exercise, bike valet at 4th/king
Cons: 3 mile bike ride, must bike through downtown, not comfortable with city biking yet (aka fearful)
Option 8: Bike to caltrain 22nd/Pennsylvania, caltrain
Duration: 1 hour, 10 minutes
Total cost: $6.00
Caltrain: $6.00
Ideal time of departure: unknown
Estimated time of arrival: 8:57 am
Pros: Exercise, faster than taking a bus
Cons: 2 mile bike ride, must bike on Cesar Chavez, no bike valet so must carry bike on train if don’t want to get it stolen, stairs down to station, afraid of biking DUH
Option 9: Drive self
Duration: unknown
Total cost: unknown
Ideal time of departure: unknown
Estimated time of arrival: unknown
Pros: Self-sufficient, independent
Cons: Parking near my apartment and downtown Palo Alto is difficult or far or expensive, too much traffic, hate driving
Option 10: BART to Milbrae -> SamTrans
Duration: 2 hours, 5 minutes
Total cost: $5.60
BART: $3.85
SamTrans: $1.75
Ideal time of departure: 7:50 am
Estimated time of arrival: 9:43 am
Pros: Cheap
Cons: Too long, unknown shared audience
And I still remain unconvinced as to which option is best. That is, if I don’t want to move away from San Francisco. Of course, there’s an option of staying at Chris’ place in Mountain View, but even there ideally I would get a ride to the destination (15 minutes) or get driven to the bus line (total bus time: 30 minutes and is $1.75) or bike (25 minutes).